Photography holds an important place in our personal lives.
We use it to record both significant and everyday moments, from family milestones and events to the more mundane. Yet many of these images hold incredible meaning for both those viewers who were present when the picture was taken and those who were not. How many times have we heard the reply to the question about the single most important possession to grab when running from one’s burning home; “my family photographs,” “photo albums,” “important pictures,” etc. Photographs are storytellers and in story we find richness and meaning about ourselves and those we love. We rely on photographs to build and pass on our family histories. Photographs are capable of evoking a sense of place, time, emotion, relationship, or connection for the viewer without telling all. Indeed, viewers complete the picture from where they sit, often arriving at clarity of self. It is all of these qualities that are so effective in aiding the dying and the bereaved.

When a baby dies parents are caught unaware as typically they move through pregnancy with awe and wonder and joyful anticipation of the day of birth. Whether a miscarriage, stillbirth, or infant death, each parent embarks on a unique path of grief facing an awful disruption of life assumptions. This is not the natural order of things. Often this may be young parents’ first encounter with death. Family, friends, and community are subsequently struck with the challenge of how to respond to and support these parents, in addition to coping with their own grief. There is oftentimes an awkward dance that occurs during bereavement where would-be supporters are not sure how to behave or communicate with bereaved parents for fear of stirring up more pain. They, too, are faced with a need to reconstruct their own realities. Some wind up doing ‘less than’ or offering platitudes they think will comfort that often do harm. For their part, some bereaved parents concerned with being the downer in social settings, may not share or socialize at all. Yet they may yearn for acknowledgement and acceptance of their baby’s existence in the family and their own place in grief—wherever that may be. When they don’t receive this acknowledgement, parents may feel the additional pain of isolation. As parents move through grief they also may struggle with holding on to memories and feelings about this short time with their baby, in the extreme some may wonder if their baby ever was.

Typically, families possess a myriad of photographs and video of their children. Families whose babies need intensive care tend not to photograph as much and consequently have few images to hold if their baby dies. Parents of stillborn babies have even fewer mementos. Documentary photographs taken of these babies in the time parents have to spend with them can help to tell their “story.”

My documentary bereavement photographs are made after delivery, in the hospital labor and delivery area or in the neonatal intensive care unit; during the private time parents have to hold their dying or dead baby. I work to create photographs that can serve as a gentle link to memories and feelings pertaining to the precious short time spent with their baby. Working unobtrusively as a willing participant, I make images about this experience without posing or electronic flash. Though the images typically show mom and dad with their baby, often other family and caregivers are included, and religious rituals may be performed. These significant caring relationships and rituals are important to render and I also strive to elucidate the emotional and spiritual energy in the room.

During more than nine years of this work, I’ve learned from parents that the photographs facilitate their grieving by:

  • making their baby’s life and death real for them—a significant issue with perinatal death and an acknowledgement so important for parents;
  • validating their feelings, both at the time of their baby’s death and up to the present;
  • being an affirmation of parenthood;
  • providing a tangible record of their time with their baby, including cherished close-up details of their baby's physical features and evidence of loving familial bonds;
  • allowing them to connect with the many feelings and memories that may have gotten lost in the torrent of overwhelming grief at the time or in the weeks since;
  • offering them an illustrated narrative of "their story" for themselves and the loved ones they choose to share it with, fostering greater social support and connection.

Documentary photography, like documentary film, while not directly manipulating the scene being photographed, is yet a subjective activity determined by “the point of view” of the photographer. When I come to these sacred places with grieving families, I need to exclude busy thoughts and hold mindfulness for “this” moment. I must slow down and diffuse any expectations and judgments within. I strive to be open to the emotional energy and the visual information I find in the room “now.” Only then am I prepared to make the most meaningful photographs for grieving parents. When I am successful, the images seem to make themselves. This presence brings me closer to the family; I become more engaged personally, thereby infusing the photographs with collaborative energy—their and mine.

All the parents I photograph share that these photographs play a significant role in helping them grieve and heal. As time passes, the images enable parents to hold onto precious memories even as they move forward in their lives. Photographs also help parents find the treasure in their adversity. They are an affirmation of these beloved babies’ lives, and are held dear by bereaved parents.

In witnessing birth and death of newborns so intertwined I am keenly aware of both the essence of life and it’s fragility. These experiences open my heart, and through the sadness I witness and feel with families, I am buoyed by what we share at a soulful, human place. All else falls away when I am with them. It is both a privilege and an honor to be invited into such a private, tragic time in their lives. I am grateful to these families for understanding the value of sharing their photographs and for graciously allowing me to present them in this manner.

 

     
All photographs copyright © Todd Hochberg